I just started 애니, it’s speculative fiction! I was not expecting SF in this collection, I wonder how it will connect to judicial topics (if it does).
법의 체면
Updates
I finished the third story 완전범죄, it was a really engrossing legal thriller, and it ends with a chilling revelation. Thinking about it is really scary, especially since I could definitely see this happen in real life.
It’s surreal to think that random elements (like an overly zealous prosecutor, and a biased, prejudiced judge) can dramatically shift the course of a trial and lead to drastically different repercussions on the accused.
I’m halfway through the third short story, 완전 범죄. It’s a really engrossing legal thriller, so tense! It shows the difference between accidental negligence and murder by omission, the latter being rare and difficult to prove.
So far the short stories have all been engrossing and educational in a good way. I’m learning a lot about Korean law and judiciary through them. At the same time, the story feel so realistic, I have to remind myself that it’s fiction and not true crime, but it sadly feels like things that could happen irl.
The second short story was so intense! It felt more like reality than fiction, it’s scary to think someone who never harmed anyone can have their life legally destroyed by an unfortunate meeting of bad luck and bad timing. The character got investigated when she had done nothing wrong, but how the law is interpreted, the current public opinion, the police officer she faced, many factors changed a perfectly innocent citizen into a criminal.
It’s also easy to see how the right to file criminal complaints can be abused, it’s really scary.
The first short story was fantastic, it gives its name to the collection and displays a harsh critic of the judicial system in general, showing that sadly, uncovering the truth is not what the court and the judge are aiming at.
The plot was really good too, I found the short story very suspenseful, and the explanations about some aspects of the judiciary really well balanced and integrated into the plot.
I didn’t take much time to read today, so I only just started the first short story. Love the beginning!
Characters
-
김동한 Other Kim Dong-han Kim Dong-han30. Doesn’t know where to go with his life and takes part in the experiment.
-
금사원 Other Geum Sa-won Geum Sa-wonDoctor/researcher conducting a brain-connection dream experiment at a university-affiliated lab.
-
정서윤 Other Jeong Seo-yun Jung Seo-yoonTeaching assistant working at the university lab who assists Dr. Geum Sa-won with the experiment.
-
석지연 Other Seok Ji-yeon Suk Ji-yeon36, runs a massage shop aimed at female clients. She took in Bang Mi-rae, to live with her.
-
방미래 Other Bang Mi-rae Bang Mi-rae28, employee at Suk Ji-yeon's massage shop who lived with her for eight months before her death.
-
정근석 Other Jeong Geun-seok Jung Geun-seok계장係長Section chief — usually 경감Investigation section chief working under the narrator.
-
이강헌 Other I Gang-heon Lee Kang-heonCourt-appointed public defence attorney known for handling his cases half-heartedly.
-
황윤수 Other Hwang Yun-su Hwang Yoon-sooPresiding senior judge in Ji-hyeon’s trial who leads the three-judge panel.
-
임동원 Other Im Dong-won Im Dong-wonChief prosecutor in the criminal division.
-
지해림 Other Ji Hae-rim Ji Hae-rim24, employee at Seok Ji-yeon's massage shop.
-
김지환 Other Gim Ji-hwan Kim Ji-hwanNarrator’s name
-
류소이 Other Ryu So-i Ryu So-iThe young woman who calls Ji-hwan, Mi-rae’s partner.
-
변현정 Other Byeon Hyeon-jeong Byun Hyun-jungYoon-soo’s wife
-
호연정 Other Ho Yeon-jeong Ho Yeon-jungLawyer who quit prosecution 5 years ago.
-
변상일 Other Byeon Sang-il Byun Sang-ilElderly man working as a pawnbroker, accused of handling stolen goods.
-
김맹기 Other Gim Maeng-gi Kim Maeng-giMan who sold the gold turtle to Sang-il.
-
김서준 Other Gim Seo-jun Kim Seo-joonLegal affairs reporter for J Newspaper who is an old acquaintance of Yeon-jung.
-
장봉호 Other Jang Bong-ho Jang Bong-hoVictim of the duct tape murder case.
Quotes
판사마다 다른 가치관이 완전히 다른 결과를 낳기도 한다. 그 가치관은 때론 편견일 수도, 이념일 수도있다. 그게 재판의 가장 큰 리스크다. 정의감이 강한 판사가멋져 보이겠지만 나한테 일방적 분노를 가진 판사가 나를판단한다고 생각해 보라. 이보다 오싹한 일이 있을까.
자유란 것의 허상. 자유는 타고 나는 권리가 아니라 허락받는 것이었구나.
— 성혜
법은 진실이 무엇인지는 관심이 없었어요. 그들에게는 법의 체면 이 더 중요했던 겁니다…
— Byun Sang-il
Vocabulary
| Word | Hanja | Definition |
|---|---|---|
| 샌님 | a meek scholar, a bookish/gentle person, a mild-mannered man |
| Word | Hanja | Definition |
|---|---|---|
| 부작위에 의한 살인 | 不作爲에 依한 殺人 | murder by omission; homicide by nonfeasance |
| 과실치사 | 過失致死 | involuntary manslaughter; death caused by negligence |
| 고의 살인 | 故意 殺人 | intentional murder; premeditated homicide |
| Word | Hanja | Definition |
|---|---|---|
| 음란물 제조죄 | 淫亂物 製造罪 | Crime of Manufacturing Obscene Materials |
I had to read a bit about 음란물 제조죄 in South Korea, the case described in the short story definitely sounds wild for a Western reader. The problem also comes from the formal complaint (고발) system here. What is described is really shocking and scary.
Also read a bit about Ma Kwang-soo, a poet and professor at university who got arrested and convincted under obscenity laws for publishing an erotic novel, 즐거운 사라. It was in the 90s, so not long ago.
| Word | Hanja | Definition |
|---|---|---|
| 집행유예 | 執行猶豫 | suspended sentence, probation |
| 전과 | 前科 | criminal records |
| 상고이유 | 上告理由 | the grounds for an appeal |
| 기각 | 棄却 | dismissal |
| 일사부재리 | 一事不再理 | the principle of not subjecting a person to double jeopardy |
Glossary
-
이리역 폭발 사 Iri Station Explosion 1977A cargo escort lit a candle in a train transporting explosive and fled when a box took fire. He was convicted for offense by ommission.
-
세월호 침몰 사고 MV Sewol Ferry Disaster 2014The captain of the Sewol ho repeatedly instructed passengers to stay in their cabin, issued no evacuation order and one was of the first to board the rescue boat. He was sentenced to life emprisonnent for murder by omission.
-
보라매병원 사건 Boramae Hospital Incident 1997A woman was convicted of murder by omission by insisting on bringing home her husband, who had just had brain surgery and needed medical support. The doctors who complied were convicted of the doctors of aiding murder by active commission